Chara vs. Alfredsson: All-Star Rosters Set

Standard Spin: Daniel Alfredsson and Zdeno Chara were comfortable enough selecting the All-star rosters in front of the bright lights and the TV cameras Thursday, but how would they hold up in a "real" fantasy draft in the dark confines of a friend's basement?  

Imagine Alfie and the Friendly Giant locking horns with the characters in your league, trash talk raining down, half drunk and desperately calling out names that were taken three rounds ago, all the while competing with something actually on the line - ie:  big money and massively important trophies.  

Judging by some of the selections that were made, Chara and Alfredsson would be the clowns taking home town players in the first rounds, letting emotions and rivalries interfere with their selections, and passing over safe choices for flashier names.  They wouldn't stand a chance!

Here's how the "fantasy" draft went down round-by-round.  

Team Captain: Zdeno Chara (Assistant Cpt: Joffrey Lupul)

Round 1: Pavel Datysuk DET
Round 2: Tim Thomas BOS
Round 3: Evgeni Malkin PIT
Round 4: Marian Hossa CHI
Round 5: Kimmo Timonen PHI
Round 6: Corey Perry ANA
Round 7: Carey Price MON
Round 8: Phil Kessel TOR
Round 9: Ryan Suter NAS
Round 10: Jimmy Howard DET
Round 11: Brian Campbell FLA
Round 12: Patrick Kane CHI
Round 13: Dion Phaneuf TOR
Round 14: Jarome Iginla CAL
Round 15: Dennis Wideman WAS
Round 16: Marian Gaborik NYR
Round 17: Jordan Eberle EDM
Round 18: Tyler Seguin BOS
Round 19: Jamie Benn DAL


Team Captain: Daniel Alfredsson (Assistant Cpt: Henrik Lundqvist)

Round 1: Erik Karlsson OTT
Round 2: Jason Spezza OTT
Round 3: Jonathan Quick LA
Round 4: Claude Giroux PHI
Round 5: Kris Letang PIT
Round 6: Steve Stamkos TB
Round 7: Brian Elliott STL
Round 8: Shea Weber NAS
Round 9: Daniel Sedin VAN
Round 10: Dan Girardi NYR
Round 11: Keith Yandle PHX
Round 12: Milan Michalek OTT
Round 13: Henrik Sedin VAN  
Round 14: James Neal PIT
Round 15: Alex Edler VAN
Round 16: John Tavares NYI
Round 17: Scott Hartnell PHI
Round 18: Jason Pominville BUF
Round 19: Logan Couture SJ

As for the best pick, we'll proclaim Henrik Sedin in round 13 as the "steal of the draft."  That seems pretty late for a recent Art Ross winner and a guy that has spent parts of the season leading the league in points again.  It's pretty obvious that the Boston-Vancouver rivalry precluded Chara from taking either of the twins, so perhaps Alfredsson figured that out and passed on them early, knowing he would probably get them on the cheap in the late rounds...  

Or, considering Alfie spent the draft targeting teammates, it's quite possible the Sedins just got snubbed. (1/27/12)